Sector profile: Post-secondary

OVERVIEW

CUPE represents just over 73,000 members across over 230 bargaining units in the post-secondary education (PSE) sector. Our members work in universities, colleges and student organizations.

CUPE is a major union in the PSE sector, and our members work in a wide variety of positions. We organize and represent both academic and support staff. Academic staff includes instructors, researchers, teaching assistants and lab technicians. Support staff work in grounds and building maintenance, libraries, food services, caretaking, information technology, clerical support and administration.

 

ISSUES

Funding

Overwhelming evidence shows that investing in PSE makes sense for our common social and economic well-being. As Canada prepares for the impacts of a trade war with the United States, PSE institutions provide a crucial economic anchor for many communities by providing stable, good-paying union jobs in a wide range of professions. A strong post-secondary system is essential to retrain and re-skill workers whose jobs may be impacted by tariffs and other economic disruptions. It also helps in facilitating research and development that will preserve Canada’s economic prosperity and sovereignty in a rapidly changing world.

Despite these realities, both provincial and federal governments are persistently underfunding PSE. In 1982, 83% of university operating revenue came from combined provincial and federal government funding. Deep cuts made by the federal government, along with cuts made at the provincial level, have pushed the proportion of public funding down to below 50% today. 

Provinces are further dismantling public PSE funding by introducing legislation that would allow the provincial minister responsible for PSE to impose deep cuts on institutions and override collective bargaining by ministerial decree. Recent bills and “Post-Secondary Reviews” in Alberta, Ontario, Newfoundland and Nova Scotia all threaten these dramatic restructurings that pave the way for privatization. 

When governments underfund PSE, the difference is made up by tuition increases, corporate donations and contracts and more precarious work. Governments provide direct support to students to help with tuition through grants, loans or tax credits, but this funding is poorly targeted and forces students to pay up front and wait for a tax credit or loan forgiveness to come years later. 

The burden of rising tuition has been particularly heavy on international students, who can be charged much higher fees than domestic students and are often not eligible for direct supports. This has resulted in an exploitative financing model where PSE institutions have used international students to subsidize reduced public funding. In response to scapegoating around the impacts of immigrants on housing prices, the federal government, in 2024, significantly reduced the number of international student visas, accelerating the crisis of underfunding.

With multiple attacks on stable funding, many public PSE institutions are shuttering programs or closing entire campuses. This will have a negative impact on workers employed by PSE institutions but will have wider impacts on the economies and economic opportunities available to students and communities across the country.

 

Privatization 

The decline in public funding has also transformed how PSE institutions are governed and how they operate. When PSE institutions accept corporate donations and contracts, this gives private, for-profit entities more influence over institutional decision-making, including more business executives on institutional boards. PSE institutions are also turning towards financialization, with investments and real estate speculation becoming the fastest-growing part of university revenues.

One of the favoured tactics of corporatized administrations is privatizing or contracting out services. CUPE’s report, Who Pays? The cost of contracting out at Canadian post-secondary institutions identified that 83.7% of post-secondary institutions have contracted out some or all food services, while 61% have contracted out some or all custodial services. Half have contracted out both food and custodial services. Contracting out has a detrimental impact on workers. The report found that contracting out takes more than $1,000 a month out of workers’ pockets, in addition to costing them pensions, sick days and other benefits.

Contracted-out workers are also more vulnerable to attacks on their union through “contract-flipping”. Many CUPE locals are fighting against the contracting out of services currently provided by members. 

The for-profit college industry has also expanded rapidly, supported by right-wing provincial governments. In several provinces, private, for-profit colleges offer courses that can be used toward public university degrees. Some for-profit, private colleges have also signed deals that allow them to offer students a diploma from a publicly funded college when they complete their studies.

 

AI and technological change 

PSE administrations are also increasingly using new technologies to outsource work. Automation and artificial intelligence (AI) technologies have been used to replace custodial and groundskeeping workers with robotic cleaners, and a growing amount of academic labour, such as marking and grading, is being performed by AI computer programs. Most of these technologies are controlled by for-profit tech companies based in the United States that are contracted by PSE administrations. This can lead to workers employed by public PSE institutions losing work or an intensification of work as these privately controlled technologies create new pressures and responsibilities for workers. CUPE has developed an AI Bargaining Guide to assist locals with negotiating on issues around digitalization and AI.

 

Health and safety, sexual harassment, and violence 

One of the largest risks to health and safety is the growing backlog of deferred maintenance on PSE campuses. Students and workers are learning and working in substandard, deteriorating facilities, often posing safety risks including slips and falls, exposure to harmful chemicals and poor lighting. The funding framework for PSE institutions encourages administrations to invest in new buildings and other “capital development” like new machines over repairing and improving existing facilities. 

CUPE is committed to addressing and preventing sexual violence in our workplaces. There are unique factors to consider when it comes to post-secondary institutions. CUPE developed Tools on Sexual Violence and Harassment in Post-Secondary Education to assist and support local executives, union stewards and members to navigate the process of responding to and preventing sexual violence and harassment within the sector. Our priority is fostering a culture of consent on campus, which is more effective than purely punitive measures. 

 

BARGAINING

Wages and benefits

Cuts to government funding have significant impacts on the wages, benefits and working conditions of workers, including CUPE members. Precarious work, outsourcing, privatization and corporatization are all on the rise in PSE. CUPE continues to face challenging rounds of bargaining due to underfunding in the sector. 

In 2023-24, the sector saw significant wage settlements negotiated, which factored in a period of high inflation. These settlements were often hard-fought and hard-won, reflecting the broader trend of increased labour militancy in Canada. In many cases, CUPE units made gains in PSE through coordinated bargaining strategies. At Queen’s University in Kingston, CUPE locals played a key role in the Queen’s Unity Council, which coordinated bargaining across all campus unions. CUPE 3902 and 3261 at the University of Toronto coordinated their bargaining across multiple bargaining units to win substantial financial gains. 

While refusing to commit to adequate public funding, provincial governments regularly involve themselves in collective bargaining by setting wage mandates for the PSE sector. While Ontario’s Bill 124 restricting wages across the entire public sector was repealed, governments in Alberta, BC and elsewhere continue to try to set wage mandates ahead of collective bargaining. There is also a worrying trend of legislation like Nova Scotia’s Bill 12 and Ontario’s Bill 33, which attacks PSE autonomy and seeks to override free and fair collective bargaining.

 

Precarious work

Declining government funding and increasing corporatization of PSE administrators contribute to an increased reliance on precarious forms of employment by PSE institutions. CUPE research shows that 54% of faculty appointments in Canadian universities have been contract appointments, rather than permanent ones. Part-time, casual and temporary terms of work have also expanded in support roles. Contracting out also facilitates increasing precariousness. In some cases, universities and colleges are using attrition to get around collective agreement protections in order to replace permanent positions with casual and temporary ones.

The impacts of the federal government’s changes to the international student visa and related programs underscore the adverse impacts of precarious work. PSE employers have offset the loss of international student tuition revenue by cancelling or not renewing contract teaching positions, circumventing normal layoff rights. 

 

Pensions

Most university pension plans are employer-sponsored. Most college plans are multi-employer plans established and regulated through provincial legislation. For the most part, these are defined benefit pension plans. Since the 2008 recession, employers have attacked pension plans by cutting benefits and shifting risk to employees, most notably by moving from defined benefit plans to defined contribution or target benefit plans. The fight for stable, jointly controlled pensions for PSE workers is ongoing.